What each Arizona college’s own pages say about appealing a final grade: what can be appealed, the first step, the time limit to start, the formal steps in order and who decides, with a link to the full procedure.
Every indented line below is copied from the college’s own page. What can be appealed, the time limits, the steps and who decides appear only in those lines, never in ours.
Grade appeal rules differ from college to college, and sometimes from one track to another at the same college. A line quoted from one college says nothing about another.
Lines about other complaints, offices and outside bodies are shown apart, under their own heading. They are not the grade appeal steps.
A topic missing under a college means we found no sentence to quote on the pages we read. It does not mean the college has no rule on it; ask the college.
Pick your college to see what its own pages say about appealing a final grade.
Your pick is saved on this device only.
Narrow the list
Each filter keeps the colleges whose quoted pages speak to that topic for a grade appeal. A college left out of a filter may still have a rule on it; its own page is the final word.
Showing 17 of 17 colleges.
Sources:
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The first step
“The steps outlined here, beginning with step A, must be followed by any student seeking to appeal a grade.”
What can be appealed
“The aggrieved student must first undergo the informal procedure of conferring with the instructor, stating any evidence and reasons for questioning that the grade received was given in good faith.”
The first step
“The instructor is obliged to review the matter, explain the grading procedure used and show how the grade in question was determined.”
Applies to: only when the instructor is a graduate assistant
“If the instructor is a graduate assistant and this interview does not resolve the difficulty, the student may then take the problem to the faculty member in charge of the course (regular faculty member or director of the course sequence).”
What can be appealed
Applies to: courses taught by another institution under a formal agreement with ASU (such as the PLuS Alliance)
“Students enrolled in courses taught by another institution through a formal ASU partnership (e.g., the PLuS Alliance) must follow the grade grievance and appeal process of the institution teaching the course.”
Deadline to start
“Student grade appeals must be processed in the regular semester immediately following the issuance of the grade in dispute (by commencement for fall or spring) regardless of whether the student is enrolled at the university.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
“If the grading dispute is not resolved in step A, the student may appeal to the department chair or other appropriate chair of the area within the department (if any).”
“The department chair may confer with the instructor to handle the problem.”
“Step B applies only in departmentalized colleges or schools.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
“If these discussions are not adequate to settle the matter to the complainant's satisfaction, the student may then confer with the dean of the college or school concerned (or the dean-designate), who reviews the case.”
“If unresolved, the dean or designate may refer the case to the college or school academic grievance hearing committee for formal review.”
“In most instances, however, the grievance procedure does not go beyond this level.”
“The following procedure takes place after steps A, B and C (or A and C) have been completed.”
“Each college or school has on file in the office of the dean (and in each department of the college or school) the procedures and composition of the undergraduate or graduate academic grievance hearing committee for student grievances.”
“The committee always meets with the student and the instructor in an attempt to resolve the differences.”
“At the conclusion of the hearing, the committee sends its recommendations to the dean.”
Who decides
“Final action in each case is taken by the dean after full consideration of the committee's recommendation.”
“Any recommended grade changes may be made by the dean.”
“The dean informs the student, instructor, department chairperson (if any), registrar and grievance committee of any action taken.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
Where other complaints go
“It is university policy that students filing grievances and those who are witnesses be protected from retaliation.”
Contact (another process)
Applies to: students who believe they are victims of retaliation (not the contact for filing a grade appeal)
“A student who believes they are a victim of retaliation should immediately contact the dean of the college or school in which the course is offered.”
Sources:
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
What can be appealed
“Acceptable grounds for appeal include suspected mathematical errors in computing the final grade or misinterpretation of grading criteria.”
“Except in the most unusual circumstances, appeals challenging the academic judgment of faculty are not acceptable.”
What can be appealed
“Changes of grade are not permitted after a degree is conferred.”
The first step
“Students who wish to appeal a final course grade are encouraged to first communicate directly with the course instructor to discuss and attempt to resolve the issue as soon as possible after grades are posted.”
Read together
These time limits do not all start from the same point. Read each one with its own step.
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The first step
Applies to: the Daytona Beach and Prescott campuses
“A student who believes the grade received for a course is inaccurate should first appeal the matter to the instructor.”
The formal steps, in order
Applies to: the Daytona Beach and Prescott campuses
“The Department Chair will review, consult with the instructor, and notify the student in writing.”
Applies to: the Daytona Beach and Prescott campuses
“If unresolved, submit the original petition, Department Chair’s decision, and supporting documentation to the College Dean (or designee).”
Who decides
Applies to: the Daytona Beach and Prescott campuses
“The Dean will render the final decision and notify the student in writing.”
Applies to: the Daytona Beach and Prescott campuses
“A copy will be sent to the Office of the Registrar.”
Deadline to start
Applies to: the Daytona Beach and Prescott campuses
“An appeal to the professor must be submitted within 30 days after the conclusion of the course.”
Applies to: the Daytona Beach and Prescott campuses
“A written petition to the Department Chair must be submitted within 45 days of the initial grade posting.”
Applies to: the Daytona Beach and Prescott campuses
“A written petition to the Dean must be submitted within 60 days of the initial grade posting.”
Applies to: the Daytona Beach and Prescott campuses
“No appeals will be considered beyond published deadlines.”
Pages behind this box:
The first step
“Appeals concerning previously assigned grades are specifically processed through the academic administrative chain, beginning with the course instructor.”
Where other complaints go
These lines point to other complaint routes, offices and outside bodies. They are not the steps of a grade appeal.
“The Dean of Students Office will provide advice and guidance to students who present grievances or complaints, whether personal or academically-related.”
“The Dean of Students Office will provide general guidance on the grade appeal process and other academically-related issues.”
Applies to: the Daytona Beach and Prescott campuses
“Any student, at any time, may choose to file a formal written grievance with the Dean of Students Office and can start by selecting the online Grievance Form for the Daytona Beach Campus or the Prescott Campus.”
Sources:
Read the full procedure Large PDF.
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
What can be appealed
“End-of-course grades: Faculty are responsible for issuing earned grades.”
“The University supports this assessment made by the faculty based on student performance throughout the course, and overturning a grade is unlikely and only if miscalculation occurred.”
“GCU does not condone rounding grades, and therefore that is not considered miscalculation.”
“A student cannot appeal final grades earned without ample evidence the grade earned was indeed miscalculated, and documentation of the student and faculty communication about the alleged miscalculation of the overall course grade.”
“Students may not file a grade appeal with the University for a grade/score on an individual assignment while the course is in progress.”
What can be appealed
Context: listed under “Not Appealable Policies”
“Grade appeals where the student has not provided evidence that it meets the terms outlined in the of the end-of-course grades requirements and guidelines”
The first step
“Informal resolution process: University departments may attempt to address student concerns through an informal resolution process which is separate from the formal University Appeal procedure.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The first step
“Students are strongly encouraged to discuss the intended appeal with a Counselor prior to submission.”
“Students must initiate the appeal process by contacting their Counselor, who will provide the student with the information needed to complete the University Appeal.”
The formal steps, in order
Context: table row “End-of-course grades”, column “1st Appeal Level”
“Program chair or equivalent in the appropriate college”
Context: table row “End-of-course grades”, column “2nd Appeal Level”
“Dean of the appropriate college or designee”
“The student may escalate the appeal to the second level by submitting another request.”
“A second appeal decision requires additional documentation to justify a re-submission of the matter.”
“Not liking the first level decision is not justification for filing a second appeal.”
Who decides
“The second level of appeal decision is the final decision of the University.”
The first step
“All supporting documentation should clearly and explicitly describe the appealed matter (including the actual policy being appealed), demonstrating the student attempted in good faith to resolve the concerns with the involved parties.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
Deadline to start
“Appeals received after the following deadlines will not be considered for review:”
“Appeals for End of Course Grades: no later than five weeks after grades are posted for the course involving the appeal matter.”
“Appeals for a published policy: no later than five weeks after the onset of appeal matter.”
“Appeals deemed Incomplete that require additional documentation: no later than five weeks of notification date.”
“If a student chooses to dispute the first appeal decision, the second appeal must be filed within five weeks of the notification date of the first appeal decision.”
The formal steps, in order
“The appeal must be completed and submitted by the student, in accordance with FERPA guidelines.”
Applies to: appeals returned as incomplete for missing documentation
“It is the responsibility of the student to submit additional requested documentation within 5 weeks of the notification.”
Applies to: all GCU University Appeals (not only grade appeals)
“The University makes every effort to come to a decision and notify the student within 15 business days of receipt of the appeal.”
Applies to: all GCU University Appeals (not only grade appeals)
“Appeal decisions are communicated to the student through postal letter.”
Contact
“Any questions regarding the appeal must be communicated to the assigned Counselor.”
Where other complaints go
These lines point to other complaint routes, offices and outside bodies. They are not the steps of a grade appeal.
“If the student complaint cannot be resolved after exhausting the Institution’s grievance procedure, the student may file a complaint with the Arizona State Board for Private Postsecondary Education.”
Sources:
What can be appealed
“A final course grade assigned by an instructor may be appealed by a student following the procedures defined below.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
What can be appealed
“A grade appeal should be considered only in instances where an instructor demonstrated a substantial deviation from accepted and specified standards as outlined by the instructor, program, college/school/department, or university.”
“Generally, such deviations are evidenced by but not limited to the following:”
“The instructor deviated substantially from the course syllabus.”
“The instructor deviated substantially from accepted and specified standards of proficiency of the University and/or academic department as established by the Faculty Handbook and/or college/school/department Academic Policy Manual.”
“The instructor applied established classroom policies unevenly and/or inequitably across students enrolled in the class.”
“The instructor applied established academic assessment methods unevenly and/or inequitably across students enrolled in the class.”
What can be appealed
“If the grade appeal is based on an allegation or finding of an academic integrity violation, then the student must follow the Academic Integrity Policy procedures, as this is not considered a grade appeal.”
“Group grade appeals are generally not permitted.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The first step
“Within the allotted time frame established in this policy, the student will provide a Statement of Issues to the instructor outlining the reasons why the grade should be reviewed.”
“This is considered initiation of the appeal process.”
“Within ten (10) business days after the student has communicated a proper request, a student-instructor meeting must be scheduled, and if possible, conducted to discuss the appeal.”
Applies to: the Level 1 student-instructor meeting
“Both the student and the instructor may bring a silent observer to this meeting.”
“Within ten (10) business days, the instructor makes a decision and sends a written communication to the student documenting the meeting and confirming the decision that was made.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
Deadline to start
“Appeal of a course grade received in a fall or winter session must be initiated within the first fifteen (15) business days of the following spring term (for 16-week courses) or session (for courses that run less than 16 weeks).”
“Appeal of a course grade received in a spring or summer session must be initiated within the first fifteen (15) business days of the following fall term (for 16-week courses) or session (for courses that run less than 16 weeks).”
“*Due to typical academic calendars and faculty workload expectations, the appeal process will generally be conducted only during the fall and spring academic terms.”
“If the student fails to initiate the first step within the timeline above, then the grade the student originally received will remain final.”
“A request for an extension of time for this process due to extenuating circumstances may be submitted to the designated administrator for the grade appeal.”
Read together
The committee decision and the appeal to the Office of the Provost are set out together in the policy. Read these lines as one, each with its tag.
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
“Within three (3) business days of receipt of the written communication, the student may request a review if they dispute the instructor’s decision.”
“This review will be requested from the designated administrator of the department where the course resides.”
“Upon receiving a timely written request from the student, the designated administrator will call a meeting of the student, instructor, and themselves.”
“Within three (3) business days of receipt of the written communication, the student may request an appeal if they dispute the designated administrator’s decision.”
“This review will be requested through the associate dean of the college where the course resides.”
“Upon receiving a timely written request from the student, the associate dean will appoint, schedule, and convene an ad hoc committee to hear the appeal.”
Who decides
“After deliberations, the chair will dismiss all parties except the ad hoc committee, and call for a vote by the committee members of whether the original grade will be affirmed or changed.”
“The decision of the Dean’s ad-hoc Committee is a final and binding decision.”
“The only grounds for appeal to the Provost’s Office are violations of the procedures outlined in this policy.”
Applies to: only appeals to the Office of the Provost over violations of the policy’s procedures
“Should this be the case, the matter may be appealed in writing to the Office of the Provost within ten (10) business days from the distribution date on the hearing result memo sent to the student, instructor, and designated administrator.”
Applies to: appeals to the Office of the Provost over violations of the policy’s procedures (the ASC Sub-committee decision)
“This decision shall be final; there is no appeal beyond this level.”
Who decides
“Only the faculty member who assigned an original grade has the authority to change that grade, with the exception of grade changes implemented by this policy.”
While the appeal is under way
“Throughout the appeal process, the original assigned grade remains as the student’s official grade until the point where it may be modified as a result of this process.”
Sources:
What can be appealed
“Students are entitled to fundamental fairness in treatment from the instructor, as specified by the course syllabus policies (Undergraduate and Graduate).”
“Grading standards of students in the same course section must be consistent.”
“Students who believe these policies have been violated may choose to file a grade appeal.”
“A student may appeal their final course grade by using the following procedures.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
What can be appealed
Context: listed under “Valid reasons for appeal include:”
“violation of university policy”
“failure to follow published course policies”
“inconsistent grading within the student’s course section”
“disagreement over factual accuracy of graded work”
Context: listed under “Invalid reasons for appeal include:”
“disagreement with published course policies”
“differences in grading policies between other courses or sections of the same course”
“impact of disputed grade on student’s academic progress or eligibility”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
What can be appealed
“A grade appeal is only available before the student’s degree is awarded.”
While the appeal is under way
Applies to: graduating students completing their last degree requirements
“When the appeal is resolved or the dean makes a final decision, the student's degree will be awarded for the term when all requirements were satisfied.”
The first step
“Prior to filing an official grade appeal, the student should discuss the concerns with the course instructor or faculty member responsible for the course.”
“It is important for a student to initiate this conversation as soon as possible in order to meet the deadline should they choose to file an appeal.”
“If concerns over a course grade are not resolved satisfactorily after speaking with the instructor, students may file a grade appeal.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
Deadline to start
“Step 1 (Student): Students must submit all forms and supporting documentation to the instructor and department head within the first five weeks of the regular term after the term in which the grade was awarded.”
“The dean's decision on whether or not the deadlines have been met is final.”
“The dean has authority to extend the deadlines, but only in extraordinary circumstances will the appeal be extended beyond the first regular term.”
The formal steps, in order
“Additional documentation may not be introduced once the grade appeal is submitted, unless requested by the instructor, department head, or dean.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
“NOTE: If the instructor is not available or does not resolve the matter to the student's satisfaction within a two-week period*, the student may resubmit the appeal to the department head within the following week.”
“*For grade appeals submitted during the summer term, the instructor will respond within 2 weeks of the start of the fall term.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
“Step 3 (Department Head): The department head will consider the written statements of the student and instructor, confer with each, and inform both parties of the recommendation in writing within one week of completion of step 2.”
“The instructor will notify the student and department head of their decision in writing within one week of receiving the department head’s recommendation.”
“NOTE: If the department head does not act on or resolve this matter to the student's satisfaction within a two-week period, the student may resubmit the appeal to the dean within the following week.”
“a. Within one week of completion of step 3, the dean will review the student's appeal.”
“At the dean’s sole discretion, the dean may convene a committee to review and make a recommendation.”
“The committee will make a written report with recommendations and provide copies to the student, the instructor, the department head, and the dean within two weeks of being convened by the dean.”
Who decides
“c. Within one week of receiving the committee recommendation and within 4 weeks of completion of step 3, the dean will make a final decision.”
“The dean has the authority to change the grade, depending on the course grading basis and the basis chosen by the student at registration.”
“The department head, the instructor, the student, and the Office of the Registrar will be notified in writing of the dean's decision.”
The formal steps, in order
“Written verification of each step is critical.”
“Students should keep documentation of submission for each step, whether submission is completed electronically or physically.”
“If at any step the student is satisfied with the response provided or feels the matter has been resolved, they may close the appeal by opting out of the remaining steps.”
Contact
“Current process, deadlines, and the grade appeal form are defined by the Office of the Registrar.”
Sources:
These two sources differ
The college’s incident-reporting page sends grade appeals to Procedure 551.2. Procedure 551.2 itself is written about instructional issues. Read both pages.
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
What can be appealed
“Students may appeal academic decisions regarding grades or other actions resulting from their academic performance.”
“Appeals or petitions regarding instructional or academic issues will be processed according to College procedure #551.2 Instructional Grievance Petition.”
Deadline to start
“Students must follow the proper steps in the appeal process, observing the time limits for completing various steps.”
The formal steps, in order
“If not satisfied with the results of this meeting, the student should repeat this procedure with the next supervisor until the level of Dean is reached.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
Context: listed under “The Statement of Appeal must contain the following information:”
“2.1.1 The student’s name, local address and telephone number and AWC ID#.”
“2.1.2 A statement of concerns regarding the original decision.”
“2.1.3 Arguments supporting the student’s position.”
“2.1.4 A statement of the requested solution.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
“If not satisfied with the Dean’s decision, the student may submit a request for final appeal in writing to the Vice President for Learning Services within five (5) business days from receipt of the decision of the Dean.”
“This appeal must contain all the original materials submitted in the informal appeal plus a copy of the written decision of the Dean.”
Who decides
“The Vice President or designee will conduct inquiries as deemed appropriate and shall provide a written decision to the student within five (5) business days.”
The formal steps, in order
Applies to: an appeal to the Vice President for Learning Services
“An appeal to the Vice President shall be limited to one or more of the following reasons:”
Applies to: an appeal to the Vice President for Learning Services
“3.3.1 Failure to follow provisions of this procedure or other applicable procedures with such failure resulting in prejudice to the student.”
Applies to: an appeal to the Vice President for Learning Services
“3.3.2 Unlawful, arbitrary, or capricious action.”
Applies to: an appeal to the Vice President for Learning Services
“3.3.3 Excessively severe sanction(s).”
Applies to: an appeal to the Vice President for Learning Services
“3.3.4 Newly discovered evidence that could not have reasonably been discovered prior to the instructor, supervisor, or Dean’s decision.”
Who decides
“The Vice President for Learning Services decision on the appeal is final.”
The formal steps, in order
“The Dean or designee will then conduct such inquiries as deemed appropriate and shall provide a written decision to the student within fifteen (15) business days.”
“The Dean’s decision may bring the matter to closure.”
Applies to: Procedure 551.2 informal step 1.2 (after the conversation with the instructor)
“This supervisor may be a director, coordinator, or associate dean.”
Applies to: Procedure 551.2 informal step 1.2 (after the conversation with the instructor)
“In this informal meeting the student will be expected to verbally explain the situation, indicate concerns and suggest possible solutions.”
Applies to: Procedure 551.2 informal step 1.2 (after the conversation with the instructor)
“If the next level supervisor is the level of Dean, the student may omit this step and move directly to 1.3.”
Where other complaints go
These lines point to other complaint routes, offices and outside bodies. They are not the steps of a grade appeal.
“Appeals of disciplinary College procedure #550.1 Student Code of Conduct.”
Sources:
Read the full procedure Large PDF; the link opens at the grade appeal page.
The lines we could quote for this college do not set out a full grade appeal procedure. The college’s own pages are the final word.
What can be appealed
“The student has the right to an explanation of an instructor’s grading procedure and how a particular grade was determined.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
Deadline to start
“Only in exceptional cases shall a grade appeal be heard at times other than during the regular academic year (fall and spring semesters.)”
“In no case shall the appeal process extend beyond the end of the first semester following the awarding of the grade without the consent of all parties involved.”
“The Dean will decide if the time constraints have been satisfied.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
Contact
“The grade appeals procedure and form are located at https://cm.maxient.com/reportingform.php?CentralAZCollege&layout_id=4.”
The formal steps, in order
“Select grade appeal as the nature of the report and selecting Academic Concern in the description.”
“A detailed reason why the student is requesting the appeal as well as steps taken up to the point of submission is required.”
“Please be aware that providing false information to a College Official is a violation of the Student Code of Conduct.”
Sources:
What can be appealed
“Students have the opportunity to appeal grades based on performance and on exceptions to college policy.”
“Student evaluations and assignments of final course grades are the responsibility of the faculty.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
What can be appealed
“A student may request that an assigned grade be changed.”
The first step
“Students should first discuss their grade with their instructor, either in person or by email.”
“If that discussion does not resolve the student’s complaint, then the procedure in the following chart shall be used.”
Deadline to start
Applies to: Procedure 3011.1 Appeal Based on Performance
“1. The change must be requested prior to the end of the first semester of enrollment (excluding summer) following the term in which the grade was assigned.”
What can be appealed
“2. An instructor may not change an F grade to a W grade in those cases that the student did not follow the proper procedures for dropping the course.”
The formal steps, in order
“3. If the instructor of record is no longer available, then the Academic Dean for the discipline shall complete the instructor’s portion of the appeal process.”
What can be appealed
“A student may appeal an academic or instructional decision if they deem it to be unfair or made in error.”
The first step
“Students who have complaints, grievances or personal concerns about a Cochise College course, instructor or grade are encouraged to first discuss the problem with their instructor.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
Context: table, step 1, column “Person Responsible”
“1 Student appeals grade to Academic Dean.”
Context: table, step 1, column “Action”
“Sends the Academic Appeal Form, a formal notice of appeal, and all evidence to the Academic Dean responsible for the discipline.”
Context: table, step 1, column “Possible Results”
“The Dean has five academic days* to consider the appeal.”
“Either way, the Academic Dean must notify the student and instructor of the decision in writing within three academic days of making the decision.”
“* Deadlines can be adjusted by mutual consent.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
Context: table, step 2, column “Person Responsible”
“2 Student or instructor appeals the Academic Dean’s decision.”
Context: table, step 2, column “Action”
“Sends all appeal documentation to the Dean who is the co-chair of the Academic Standards Committee.”
“This information must get to the Dean within five academic days from the conclusion of the previous step.”
Context: table, step 2, column “Possible Results”
“A 3-person subcommittee selected by either of the co-chairs of the Academic Standards committee will hear the appeal as soon as possible after the appeal is requested.”
Who decides
“If the subcommittee votes to change the student’s grade, then the Dean who is the co-chair of the Academic Standards committee will submit a change of grade form to the Registrar.”
“The Dean who is the co-chair of the Academic Standards committee will notify the student, instructor, and Academic Dean of the decision in writing within five academic days following the hearing.”
“The Academic Standards committee is the final authority for appeals based on performance.”
The formal steps, in order
Applies to: the formal grade appeal hearing (Procedure 3011.1)
“The advisor may be an attorney; however, the advisor may not participate in the hearing.”
While the appeal is under way (another process)
Applies to: Procedure 3011.3 academic integrity appeals, not grade appeals
“A student must be allowed to continue to attend the class in which dishonesty has been alleged until the right of appeal has been exhausted unless the student has been officially suspended in accordance with policy 3010.”
Where other complaints go
These lines point to other complaint routes, offices and outside bodies. They are not the steps of a grade appeal.
“Students who are still dissatisfied may contact the appropriate academic dean or director or submit a student complaint to the Associate Vice President of Student Services.”
“Academic complaints, such as grade appeals, are not reviewed by the Arizona SARA Council and should not be submitted to that organization for review.”
Sources:
What can be appealed
“Academic Appeal A request to alter a grade or other academic decision based upon sound reasoning and/or clear and compelling evidence.”
“The Academic Appeals procedure is to be used for appeals of grades and other academic decisions only.”
“Students who pursue appeals under false pretenses may be subject to disciplinary action under Procedure 503-01 Student Code of Conduct.”
The first step
“The goal of the informal academic appeal process is to provide information to the student that answers their questions and concerns and/or to come to a resolution agreeable to both the student and the College.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
Deadline to start
“To address academic appeals in a timely fashion, the student must begin the informal process within ten (10) College working days of the disputed grade or academic decision being issued by the instructor.”
The first step
“Every effort will be made to resolve the appeal at the lowest level.”
“1. First, conferring directly with the instructor who issued the grade or academic decision and attempting to resolve the appeal.”
“Students, instructors, and supervisors (when applicable) will each take notes regarding the informal appeal and resolution and keep these notes in their personal records.”
Deadline to start
“Failure to begin the informal complaint process within the timeframes set forth in this Procedure shall constitute a waiver of the complaint.”
“Failure at any step of this Procedure to appeal to the next level within the specified timelines described herein shall be deemed acceptance of the decision rendered at that step and there shall be no further right of appeal.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
“The Dean receiving the formal academic appeal will forward a copy to the instructor and their lead faculty supervisor (in the case of part-time instructors only).”
“The Dean will work with all parties involved and the other instructional Dean to mediate the appeal in a timely manner.”
“Within ten (10) College working days, the Dean will notify the student of the outcome in writing.”
“If all parties accept the decision, it will be considered final.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
Context: listed under “The formal academic appeal must contain the following information:”
“1. Name of the student(s) filing the formal academic appeal.”
“2. Name of the instructor.”
“3. Statement of facts and nature of the formal academic appeal.”
“4. Date(s) of the incident(s).”
“5. Resolution being sought by the student(s).”
“6. Student's signature.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
Who decides
Context: listed under “The Committee may take one or more of the following actions:”
“1. Uphold the Level 2 decision.”
“2. Overturn the Level 2 decision in light of procedural concerns and/or new evidence.”
“3. Remand the appeal to the dean for further consideration in light of procedural concerns and/or new evidence.”
“The Academic Appeals Committee’s decision on an academic appeal is final.”
Where other complaints go
These lines point to other complaint routes, offices and outside bodies. They are not the steps of a grade appeal.
“If another appeal procedure exists for the grievance in question, the student will be referred to the appropriate procedure.”
What can be appealed
“If a student desires to appeal a grade, that student must follow the grievance process outlined in the Official Review Process under Grievance Procedures - Academic Standards.”
“Students aggrieved by College actions of an academic nature shall have the opportunity for appeal.”
“The professional educator’s qualifications and rights to determine academic standards are respected and accepted.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
What can be appealed
“The student’s right for grievance shall be forfeited if the complaint is not addressed through the Official Review Process - Academic Standards.”
Where other complaints go
“Complaints of sexual harassment should follow the procedure set forth in GCCCD Policy 2075.01 - Procedures for Alleged Violations of the Title IX Sexual Harassment Regulations.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The first step
“Step 1. The Complainant shall seek out, within five (5) days of the action, the Professional Educator so both parties may be afforded an opportunity to clarify facts and to reach a mutually acceptable solution.”
Deadline to start
“Days: Calendar days exclusive of official holidays as identified in the College Catalog.”
While the appeal is under way
“The appeal process does not suspend any actions which are being grieved.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
“Step 2. If Complainant satisfaction is not achieved in Step 1, the Complainant shall provide a written request for a meeting to the Academic Dean responsible for oversight of the standards employed by the Professional Educator.”
“Within five (5) days of receipt of the request the Academic Dean shall arrange for a meeting to include the following individuals: the Academic Dean, the Professional Educator, and the Complainant.”
“The Academic Dean shall attempt to mediate an acceptable solution.”
“Step 3. If Complainant satisfaction is not achieved in Step II, the Complainant shall provide a written request for a hearing by the Academic Standards Appeals Committee.”
“Within ten (10) days of receipt of the request, but not less than three (3) days of receipt of request, the Chairperson of the Academic Standards Appeals Committee shall arrange for a hearing.”
“The Complainant, the Professional Educator and the Academic Dean shall attend the hearing.”
Who decides
“Within ten (10) days of the conclusion of the hearing, the Chairperson of the Academic Standards Appeals Committee shall set forth a written document addressing finding of fact and the decision reached by the Committee.”
“Copies shall be addressed to the Complainant, the Professional Educator, the Academic Dean, and the College President.”
“Decisions made by the Academic Standards Appeal Committee are binding.”
Who decides (another process)
Applies to: grade changes in general, not the appeal decision
“Grade changes can be made through a grade change request initiated by the instructor, followed by approval of the Academic Dean or Vice President of Academic and Student Affairs.”
Where other complaints go
These lines point to other complaint routes, offices and outside bodies. They are not the steps of a grade appeal.
Applies to: clerical-error grade corrections (separate from the grade appeal)
“Grade changes due to clerical errors can be made and corrected by the Admissions and Registration Office.”
Sources:
Read the full procedure Large PDF.
These rules differ by track
Appendix S-6 sets out separate tracks, each with its own time limits. Read a time limit only with its own track.
The last level of review is not the same in every track. Read each line about it with its own track.
Track: Administrative Regulation 2.3.5 (grades)
Deadline to start
“The appeal process for grades must be initiated no later than sixty (60) calendar days from the date the grade was issued.”
Track: Final grade appeal (Appendix S-6)
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
What can be appealed
“This process is to be used to appeal the final instructional grades for a course.”
“assignment or exam grades may be reviewed in this process if they impact continuation in a program.”
Who decides
“A final grade can only be changed by the instructor of record through this process, except for extraordinary circumstances as outlined below.”
What can be appealed
“This process should not be utilized in a case in which a student feels that they have experienced discrimination or harassment.”
“In addition, a student who feels that they have experienced sexual harassment should refer to the sexual harassment policy for students.”
“Remedies under this process may include, as appropriate, a change in the grade received for the course, exam, project, or other assignment.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The first step
“A student who wants to appeal a final grade shall first attempt to resolve the issue with the full-time or adjunct faculty member involved.”
“The student shall initiate the process by submitting to the full-time or adjunct faculty member a written grade appeal explaining why they feel there is an issue with the final grade.”
“Upon receipt of the written grade appeal, the full-time or adjunct faculty member shall contact the student to make arrangements for discussing the appeal.”
“Communication may occur in person, by phone, by mail, or by online means.”
“The full-time or adjunct faculty member and student shall make reasonable efforts to conduct the meeting within fifteen (15) business days from the submission of the written grade appeal.”
The formal steps, in order
“If the full-time or adjunct faculty member is unavailable or fails to timely resolve the appeal, the student may escalate their appeal to the department/division level.”
“Upon receipt of the written appeal, the faculty chair will meet with the parties to attempt to resolve the appeal.”
“The full-time or adjunct faculty member may ask that the college faculty senate president or designee attend any meetings to advise on concerns of policy.”
“The student shall have the right to be assisted by any member of the college community they choose.”
“The college community member may not be serving in a legal capacity.”
“The meeting may take place in person, by telephone, by mail, or by online means.”
“A record of the resolution or reasons for non-resolution will be documented by the faculty chair on the intake form.”
“The VPAA or designee shall issue a written decision regarding the outcome of the appeal no later than ten (10) business days following the date of the meeting.”
Who decides
“Except as outlined below (extraordinary circumstances), this is the final level of review for appeals regarding grades.”
The first step
“The student is responsible for providing a rationale for initiating a grade appeal.”
“Any documentation to support the student’s appeal is encouraged.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
Deadline to start
“Any appeal of a final grade must be initiated no later than sixty (60) calendar days from the date the grade is issued.”
“absent exceptional circumstances, as determined at the sole discretion of the faculty chair, no untimely appeals will be considered.”
“The faculty chair or VPAA, as appropriate based on the level, may, upon a showing of good cause, extend any of the deadlines set forth in this process.”
“Alternatively, any deadline may be extended by mutual agreement of the full-time or adjunct faculty member and student.”
Track: Final grade appeal: extraordinary circumstances committee
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
Applies to: the S-6 Final Grade Appeal, extraordinary circumstances committee (at the VPAA’s discretion)
“In extraordinary circumstances and where the VPAA deems it necessary in the interest of fairness, the VPAA may convene a committee to resolve the appeal.”
Applies to: the S-6 Final Grade Appeal, extraordinary circumstances committee (at the VPAA’s discretion)Context: listed under “Examples of extraordinary circumstances”
“The faculty member is no longer employed within the district.”
Applies to: the S-6 Final Grade Appeal, extraordinary circumstances committee (at the VPAA’s discretion)
“The faculty member deviated substantially from the course syllabus or any communicated changes in the course syllabus.”
Applies to: the S-6 Final Grade Appeal, extraordinary circumstances committee (at the VPAA’s discretion)
“Other review processes of the faculty revealed inconsistencies in grading/assessment practices or unprofessional behavior.”
Applies to: the S-6 Final Grade Appeal, extraordinary circumstances committee (at the VPAA’s discretion)
“Within thirty (30) business days of seating the committee, a resolution must be reached and documented.”
Who decides
Applies to: the S-6 Final Grade Appeal, extraordinary circumstances committee (at the VPAA’s discretion)
“This is the final level of appeal for grades reviewed under this process.”
Track: Expedited grade appeal for technical errors or omissions
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
What can be appealed
“This process may be used only to resolve grade appeals regarding technical errors or omissions in calculating or recording (a) a grade on an exam, project, or other assignment, or (b) an overall course grade.”
“This is the exclusive process for appeals regarding technical errors or omissions in grading.”
Who decides
Applies to: the Expedited Grade Appeal Process for Technical Errors or Omissions
“The decision of the faculty chair is final and binding.”
Applies to: the Expedited Grade Appeal Process for Technical Errors or Omissions
“The request for the grade appeal cannot be reopened.”
Track: Instructional grievance
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
What can be appealed
“A student who feels that he or she has been treated unfairly or unjustly by a faculty member with regard to an academic process such as grading, testing, or assignments, has the right to appeal according to the approved procedures.”
Deadline to start
Applies to: the Instructional Grievance, Step One
“This conference shall be requested by the student within fifteen (15) business days from the time the student knew or reasonably should have known about the unfair or unjust treatment.”
Who decides
Applies to: the Instructional Grievance, Step Three
“This level will be the final step in any complaint process regarding grades.”
Where other complaints go
“If the complaint, other than those concerning grades, is not resolved by the VPAA or the appropriate college administrative officer, it may be forwarded in writing by the student to the college president for final resolution.”
Sources:
Read the full procedure This is the college’s complaint procedure page, not a grade appeal procedure.
The lines we could quote for this college do not set out a full grade appeal procedure. The college’s own pages are the final word.
What can be appealed
Applies to: CBE (competency-based education) studentsFrom the CBE Student Handbook, February 28, 2022
“Students who feel that a grade has been awarded unfairly must follow the College Grievance Policy and Procedures found in the Student Handbook.”
Where other complaints go
These lines point to other complaint routes, offices and outside bodies. They are not the steps of a grade appeal.
“Mohave College provides an internal complaint process that is outlined in the Student Handbook.”
“Students and prospective students may also file complaints with Mohave College’s accrediting body, the Higher Learning Commission.”
Sources:
What can be appealed
“This procedure applies to all students and faculty.”
“To describe the process by which students may appeal a grade affecting completion of, or admission to, a course and/or program.”
“The Student Appeal of Grades Procedure is to be used for appeals of grades only.”
“3.1 Appeal: A request to alter a grade or other academic decision based on sound reasoning and/or clear and compelling evidence.”
Read together
These lines name the office for a final appeal both “EVPLSS” and “VPLSS”, exactly as the procedure writes them. Ask the college which office takes a final appeal.
These lines count time in different units: business days, working days and days. Each is kept exactly as the procedure writes it.
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The first step
“The student must first make every effort to address grading decisions directly with the faculty member.”
“The goal of the informal appeal process is to address the student’s questions and/or concerns in an effort to come to a mutually agreeable resolution.”
“Within five (5) days or receiving the informal appeal, the faculty member will inform the student in writing of their grade decision.”
“If the student receives a satisfactory decision at this stage, the faculty member will update the student’s grade.”
“If the faculty member is not available, the student should contact the individual’s direct supervisor.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
Deadline to start
“a) Within fourteen (14) business days of the disputed grade, the student will:”
The first step
“In writing, contact the faculty member who made the decision in an attempt to informally resolve the appeal.”
Deadline to start
“3.3 Day: Days NPC is scheduled to be open per the academic calendar and NPC catalogue.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
“The student may initiate a formal appeal process only if the informal process was not resolved to the student’s satisfaction.”
“a) Within five (5) days of receiving the written decision of the informal appeal, the student submits a written appeal to the faculty member’s direct supervisor.”
Context: listed under “The formal grade appeal must contain the following information:”
“Name of the student(s) filing the formal grade appeal.”
“Name of the instructor.”
“Statement of facts and relevant documentation related to the formal grade appeal.”
“Date(s) of the incident(s).”
“Resolution being requested by the student(s).”
“Optional: the name of an NPC advisor or employee whom the student invites to act on behalf of the student as an advocate.”
“Student's signature.”
“The supervisor will provide a written solution to the student, faculty member, and VPLSS within five (5) days following the mediation conference.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
“If the student or instructor is not satisfied with the supervisor's decision, they may initiate a final appeal process.”
Who decides
“b)The EVPLSS will then conduct an inquiry involving all parties within ten (10) working days.”
“The EVPLSS may then elect to hear the appeal, appoint a hearing panel, or make a decision based on evidence gathered from the inquiry.”
“The VPLSS decision is final and binding.”
“Both parties will be notified in writing within twenty-five (25) working days of receiving the appeal.”
Who decides
“Situations in which a faculty member cannot be consulted regarding a grade appeal will be assessed individually beginning with the supervisor.”
Where other complaints go
These lines point to other complaint routes, offices and outside bodies. They are not the steps of a grade appeal.
“Students who believe that they have been treated unfairly may use this procedure to have their grievance considered.”
Sources:
Read the full procedure This is the college’s general complaints procedure, not a grade appeal procedure.
The lines we could quote for this college do not set out a full grade appeal procedure. The college’s own pages are the final word.
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
What can be appealed (another process)
General complaints procedure, not grade-specificContext: a row heading in the Formal Complaints Matrix
“Complaints against a faculty member by students, including grade complaints:”
The formal steps, in order (another process)
General complaints procedure, not grade-specificContext: listed under “Complaints against a faculty member by students, including grade complaints” in the Formal Complaints Matrix
“Reviewed by the Department Head”
General complaints procedure, not grade-specific
“Appeals to the Division Dean or Vice Provost”
The first step (another process)
General complaints procedure, not grade-specificApplies to: all formal complaints under Pima AP 3.31.01
“The College encourages the resolution of any complaint through direct, respectful communication between those involved.”
General complaints procedure, not grade-specificApplies to: all formal complaints under Pima AP 3.31.01
“If the parties involved cannot resolve the complaint through informal means, the complainant may initiate a Formal Complaint.”
Applies to: any student concern (Pima complaint processes page; not specific to grades)
“Students are strongly encouraged to resolve any concern by talking with the individual or faculty member and their supervisor if necessary.”
Deadline to start (another process)
General complaints procedure, not grade-specificApplies to: all formal complaints under Pima AP 3.31.01
“Whenever possible, the complainant should submit a Formal Complaint within 30 calendar days of the last incident.”
The formal steps, in order (another process)
General complaints procedure, not grade-specificApplies to: all formal complaints under Pima AP 3.31.01
“To initiate the Formal Complaint process, the complainant must submit their complaint either to a Campus Student Complaint Resource Liaison or to the Office of Dispute Resources (“ODR”).”
General complaints procedure, not grade-specificApplies to: all formal complaints under Pima AP 3.31.01
“Formal Complaints may be submitted in person, by phone, by email, by regular mail, or online.”
General complaints procedure, not grade-specificApplies to: all formal complaints under Pima AP 3.31.01
“Upon receipt of the complaint, the Campus Student Complaint Resource Liaison or ODR will assign the case to the appropriate Reviewer based on the Formal Complaints Matrix.”
General complaints procedure, not grade-specificApplies to: all formal complaints under Pima AP 3.31.01
“If the complainant or respondent believes that an error was made in the review process, the complainant or respondent may make a written appeal request.”
Who decides (another process)
General complaints procedure, not grade-specificApplies to: all formal complaints under Pima AP 3.31.01
“The appeal decision is final.”
Where other complaints go
These lines point to other complaint routes, offices and outside bodies. They are not the steps of a grade appeal.
General complaints procedure, not grade-specificApplies to: all formal complaints under Pima AP 3.31.01
“Complaints involving prohibited discrimination, harassment, or retaliation shall also be reported to ODR as required in AP 2.03.01.”
Sources:
What can be appealed
“The College has established an appeal process to provide students with a timely, respectful, and thorough review of an academic decision which they perceive to be unfair or made in error.”
“A student may appeal an academic or instructional decision by faculty if they believe the decision was made in error.”
“A student may only appeal a decision that affects him/her directly and must represent themselves in the appeal process.”
“The appeal of an academic or instructional decision requires documentation that the decision was incorrect.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The first step
“Step 1 - The first step in the appeal process is for the student to contact the faculty member who made the academic or instructional decision.”
Deadline to start
“This contact must be made within 10 business days of the official notification date of the decision.”
“For appeals concerning a final grade, official notification is considered to be the date the grade is posted to the student's permanent record.”
Deadline to start
“The appeal must be made in a timely manner in accordance with the established procedures documented below.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The formal steps, in order
“Step 2 - In the event the faculty member and student are unable to reach a mutual agreement within ten (10) business days, the student may then appeal to the appropriate Academic Dean.”
“The appeal to the Academic Dean must be made within 10 business days in writing using the official form, "Academic or Instructional Decision Appeal to the Academic Dean."”
“All documentation supporting the reason for the appeal must be provided at the time the appeal is submitted.”
“This appeal must succinctly describe the issues involved, evidence that an error was made, and any relevant information.”
“Missing, incomplete or erroneous information may cause the appeal to be rejected.”
“Step 3 - The Academic Dean will review the student's appeal and make a decision based on the documentation provided by the student, the faculty member, and other relevant information that may include meetings with appropriate individuals.”
Who decides
“The Academic Dean's investigation and decision must be concluded within 10 business days of the date the student appealed the decision to the Academic Dean.”
“The Academic Dean will provide written documentation of the decision to the student and faculty member.”
“The decision of the Academic Dean is final.”
Sources:
The lines we could quote for this college do not set out a full grade appeal procedure. The college’s own pages are the final word.
What can be appealed
“The student has the right to appeal any action affecting their academic status by obtaining the appropriate form from the Office of the Registrar: Appeal of Suspension, Appeal of Probation, Grade Appeal, or General Appeal.”
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
Who decides (another process)
Applies to: any grade change
“The Instructor and Dean of School must approve a grade change.”
The formal steps, in order
“Students wanting to appeal a grade must complete an Academic Grade Appeal form and follow the appeal process.”
What can be appealed
“Once course is completed per official last day of class, student(s) cannot submit or resubmit coursework for a higher grade.”
What can be appealed (another process)
Applies to: grade changes (clerical error or Incomplete), not reasons for a grade appeal
“Circumstances necessitating a change of grade may include a clerical error made by the instructor or data entry personnel in preparing the grade report or the change of an “Incomplete” grade.”
Applies to: grade changes in general (not the time limit for filing a grade appeal)
“With the exception of the “I” and the “IP” grade which must be changed by the end of the following semester, a grade may be changed within an academic year from the time it was given.”
Applies to: grade changes for summer courses (not the time limit for filing a grade appeal)
“Changes of grades for summer courses must be completed by the end of the following summer session.”
Where other complaints go
These lines point to other complaint routes, offices and outside bodies. They are not the steps of a grade appeal.
“Do not use this Form for grade appeals.”
Sources:
Read the full procedure This page sums up the college’s complaint routes; it is not the full grade appeal procedure.
The lines we could quote for this college do not set out a full grade appeal procedure. The college’s own pages are the final word.
Read together
One line is about grade appeals and the other is about non-academic complaints. Read each with its tag.
These lines go together on the college’s page. Read them as one.
The first step
“For any kind of complaint, we encourage students to try to resolve the situation informally, speaking directly with the instructor, staff member, or other student who is involved.”
The formal steps, in order
“If the informal approach does not work, the student may file a grade appeal or student complaint.”
What can be appealed
“For grievances about grades and other instructional matters, the Student Handbook describes the “Grading Complaints & Appeal Process.””
Who decides
“Grade Appeal Committee decisions are final.”
Where other complaints go
“For non-academic complaints, the Student Handbook lays out the “Non-Grading Student Complaint Process.””
Where other complaints go (another process)
Applies to: non-academic (Non-Grading) complaints, not grade appeals
“The highest level of appeal for in-state or resident students who have complaints is the TOCC Board of Trustees.”
Pages behind this box:
See everything for Tohono O'odham Community College on one page
Checked against official pages on November 15, 2026. Catalogs and policies change; the college’s own page is the final word.